An Enforcer is a hired hood for a particular crime family who either has yet to be made, or is not Italian but has proven his worth in battle. If an enforcer proves his mettle, he becomes a soldato of the family, sometimes referred to as 'un amico nostro' or 'a friend of ours'. Sometimes enforcers are already made men who work by themselves. Some enforcers, such as Stephen Coyne, are treated as made men but cannot be made into a family due to not being of Sicilian or Italian descent.
- Stephen Coyne (Vinci Crime Family, Unknown - 1951)
- Big Stan (Salieri Crime Family, Unknown - 1933)
- Zhe Yun Wong (Empire Bay Triads, Unknown - 1951)
- Jimmy (Gravina Crime Family, 1950s) (Jimmy DLCs)