The house served as a home for Tommy and his family after testifying against the Salieri Crime Family. In 1951, the Salieris discovered Tommy's whereabouts and asked if the Falcone Crime Family could do them a favor by killing the rat. In response, Eddie sent Vito Scaletta and Joe Barbaro to commit the murder. As Tommy waters his lawn, they pull up in front of his house and deliver the message from Mr. Salieri. Tommy is then shot in the chest by Joe, leaving him to die lying in front of his house.
- This house seems to have been slightly altered, as seen in Mafia II.